New York Islanders vs San Jose Sharks prediction
2026-11-09 · SAP Center at San Jose
Our prediction
Predicted winner
NYI
Predicted score
NYI 3 – 2 SJS
Win chance · confidence
70% · Medium
NYI's defensive and goaltending edge points to a 3–2 road win
Our analysts favor NYI at 70%, consistent with the supplied baseline. NYI have the stronger goal differential, more reliable penalty killing and a substantial goaltending advantage if Ilya Sorokin starts. SJS's five-game losing streak reinforces that assessment, but NYI's injuries and equally modest shot share keep this from being a high-confidence pick.
How we expect the game to play out
The first period should be relatively close: neither team generates a strong share of shots, and SJS have home ice. Through the second, NYI's faceoff advantage and stronger goaltending should help them establish a narrow lead, while Macklin Celebrini supplies SJS's most dangerous offensive threat. Expect SJS to push in the third, with NYI relying on saves and penalty killing to protect a one-goal margin rather than overwhelming the hosts offensively.
Key factors behind our call
- Goal differential and recent form favor NYIFavours NYIHigh impact
NYI's season differential is -2 through 16 games (-0.13 per game), versus SJS's -21 through 19 (-1.11). Recent results reinforce that gap: NYI are -6 over their last 10 and -5 over their last five; SJS are -12 and -14, respectively, with five consecutive losses.
- Shot share offers little separationFavours EVENMedium impact
SJS average 27.0 shots for and 30.1 against, while NYI average 25.4 for and 28.5 against. Both have a -3.1 shot differential per game, with approximate shot shares of 47.3% and 47.1%. NYI's scoring-results edge is not supported by a meaningful shot-volume advantage.
- Sorokin provides the strongest individual edgeFavours NYIHigh impact
Sorokin has a .910 save percentage and 2.64 GAA across 11 appearances, compared with Yaroslav Askarov's .885 and 3.35 across 12. Neither listed starter is marked out, although starts are not confirmed. The advantage narrows if Semyon Varlamov (.892) faces Alex Nedeljkovic (.895).
- Penalty killing offsets NYI's weak power playFavours NYIMedium impact
NYI kill 85.7% of penalties versus SJS's 76.5%, giving them a better answer to SJS's 21.4% power play. NYI's own power play converts only 14.6%, limiting their ability to exploit SJS's penalty-killing weakness. NYI also lead faceoff percentage, 56.1% to 47.2%.
- NYI's injury list is a meaningful cautionFavours SJSMedium impact
NYI list five unavailable players: Mathew Barzal, Ryan Pulock, Alexander Romanov, Matias Maccelli and Calum Ritchie. SJS list four: Alexander Wennberg, Igor Chernyshov, Quentin Musty and Kyle Keyser. Barzal's absence limits NYI's attacking options, while Pulock and Romanov reduce defensive depth. Neither team's starting goalie is listed out.
- Home ice helps SJS; rest is equalFavours SJSLow impact
Both teams have one rest day, so neither faces a back-to-back disadvantage. SJS receive the home-ice benefit at SAP Center, but their eight home games and NYI's seven road games come without venue-specific records in the supplied data.
- Broader results and close head-to-head wins support NYIFavours NYIMedium impact
NYI lead in points percentage, .531 to .395, and regulation wins, five to two despite playing three fewer games. They also won both meetings last season, 4–3 and 2–1. Those narrow margins support the pick without suggesting an easy victory.
Players to watch
- Ilya Sorokin (NYI) — His .910 save percentage is the best among the supplied goalies; a confirmed start would strengthen NYI's clearest matchup advantage.
- Bo Horvat (NYI) — With seven goals and 16 points in 16 games, he is a central scoring threat while Barzal remains unavailable.
- Matthew Schaefer (NYI) — Five goals and 11 assists in 16 games give NYI important offense from defense.
- Macklin Celebrini (SJS) — His 21 points in 17 games lead the supplied SJS skaters and make him their strongest candidate to overturn the matchup.
News & roster impact
No additional news or coaching/morale reports were supplied. Barzal's injury entry reports no-contact practice and no return timetable, not clearance to play. All listed absences remain part of the assessment; the empty top-scorer-out lists do not erase those injuries.
Coaching angle
There is no reported coaching change or documented morale boost to price in. The tactical priority for NYI should be protecting their depleted defense and using their faceoff edge to secure possession. SJS need to tighten coverage after allowing 22 goals over their five-game losing streak; urgency alone is not evidence of a rebound.
History & last season
This is the first meeting of the season. NYI swept last season's two games by a combined 6–4, including a 2–1 win at SJS. Last season also slightly favored NYI overall: 91 points and a -8 differential versus SJS's 86 points and -41. Current-season performance carries substantially more weight.
What could prove us wrong
The 70% estimate follows the supplied baseline, but NYI are not a dominant favorite by shot share and have gone winless in their last three listed games. Barzal's absence and the missing Pulock–Romanov defensive depth could prove more costly than expected. A Varlamov start would reduce the goaltending edge, while a strong SJS goalie performance or Celebrini-led power-play breakthrough could swing a projected one-goal game.
Model lab: probabilities, players, goalies & odds
Every pick is published before puck drop and graded automatically after the game in our results archive. See every player's strengths, weaknesses and news on our player predictions page.